How Self-Managed HOAs Should Get (and Compare) Contractor Bids
By Priya Raman · November 4, 2026
"Get three bids" is the oldest advice in association management, and it's good advice, but only if the bids are comparable. Three contractors pricing three different interpretations of "fix the drainage" gives you three numbers and no information. A short, repeatable process gets better prices, protects the association, and gives the board a record that shows good judgment.
1. Write the scope of work first
Before calling anyone, write down exactly what you need: the location, quantities, materials or quality standard, timeline, cleanup, and warranty expectations. A one-page scope is enough for most jobs. Send the same document to every bidder so you're comparing prices for the same work.
2. Invite qualified bidders
Ask neighboring associations for referrals, and look for contractors who regularly work for communities, not just single homes. Any director with a relationship to a bidder should disclose it. See handling conflicts of interest.
3. Verify license and insurance
- Check the contractor's license with your state's licensing board where one is required.
- Request a certificate of insurance showing general liability and workers' compensation, and ask that the association be named as an additional insured.
- Collect a W-9 before the first payment. The association may need to issue a Form 1099-NEC if payments pass the IRS threshold.
4. Compare like for like
Put the bids side by side: price, what's included and excluded, materials, timeline, payment schedule, and warranty. The lowest bid isn't automatically the best one. Look for exclusions that will become change orders later. Avoid large upfront deposits, and tie payments to completed milestones.
5. Decide in a meeting and document why
The board should approve the contract at a properly noticed meeting, not by a reply-all email. Record which bids were received and why the winner was chosen. That record is what earns business judgment protection if the decision is questioned. Our minutes generator keeps it clean.
6. Tell owners what's coming
Paving, painting, or tree work affects everyone's driveway and schedule. Announce dates and what to expect ahead of time with our announcement generator. Big projects should already be in your reserve study and budget, so the money is there when the work starts.
Priya Raman
Priya writes about HOA finances — budgets, dues collection, reserves, and special assessments — for volunteer treasurers.